× About Italian Jewelry Jewelry News Watch News Blog Contact Map View FAQs Return Policy Shipping
<< Back to Blog
  • Share on Socials

Our pick of 7 Top Local Stores To Buy Jewelry in Columbus

Our pick of 7 Top Local Stores To Buy Jewelry in Columbus

Columbus is famous for its bridal wedding collection, classic apparels, trendy shoes and sparkling jewelry. Whether you are looking for sparkling diamond studded jewelry or the latest funky or oxidized jewelry, some of the top jewelry shops in Columbus will offer you the most exquisite collection of contemporary and traditional jewelry. Dotted with some of the best jewelry shops in and around everywhere, it is one of the favorite shopping destinations for jewelry.

1. Diamond Cellar Go to the the online store

1. Diamond Cellar

Their founder, Robert Johnson established Robert W Johnson Incorporated, later known as the Diamond Cellar, as a trade shop in 1947. The original shop on north High Street above Kresge’s Five and Dime did jewelry repairs and alterations for retailers that didn’t have their own craftspeople. Diamond Cellar is a company dedicated, not only to preserve the natural environment but also to improving the quality of their community. As a local company, they give back by supporting a variety of charities within the community that is dedicated to making a difference.

2. Argo & Lehne Jewelers Go to the the online store

2. Argo & Lehne Jewelers

They're passionate about jewelry, art, and individual expression. They've been around for near a century because they're forward-thinking artisans who embrace your style - whatever style that may be. This is what makes them the most trusted resource for unique, one-of-a-kind jewelry that gets you. They are proud to be a third-generation jeweler, with roots in Columbus since the early 1900’s. They are who they are today because of the generations of efforts. As a result, we see the children, grandchildren, and great grandchildren of their original customers visiting them again and again.

3. Meyers Jewelers Go to the the online store

3. Meyers Jewelers

Meyers Jewelers has been in business since 1966 and has proven to be an infallible family business. They have a passionate and dedicated family behind their full-service jewelry store. Meyer, a lifelong resident of Columbus, started working for a local downtown jeweler in 1942 when he was 15 years old to help his family during The Great Depression. When he was 17, he volunteered and joined the Navy to represent the USA in World War II. He spent two years in the military and then went back home to Columbus, Ohio and back to work at the same jeweler he had worked for before the war. Twenty years later, Meyer decided to open up his own store in the Great Southern Shopping Center on the South Side of Columbus, and that was the start of Meyers Jewelers.

4. Leo Alfred Jewelers Inc. Go to the the online store

4. Leo Alfred Jewelers Inc.

Leo Alfred is committed to make every customer "feel at home" with their personalized service and their timeless to cutting edge jewelry designs. Their years of experience and services have built a legacy of integrity and trust with their customers. At Leo Alfred, in the full-service shop, custom goldsmiths, certified gemologists and appraisers are capable of everything from sizing a ring to designing a true work of art. Another important part of their approach is giving back to the community. They do so by making donations to numerous charities throughout Central Ohio such as the Dublin Fund, the Komen Columbus Race for the Cure, and many local Dublin and Columbus school events and fundraisers.

5. CDI Diamonds & Jewelry Go to the the online store

5. CDI Diamonds & Jewelry

CDI Diamonds & Jewelry is family owned and operated by Matt Carlozzi Jr. with his son Matt III since 2001 as the former Bernie Helmick Diamonds and Gold. CDI provides a customer experience based on education, selection, expertise and a no pressure approach. They take every effort to stay ahead of the curve on both style and technology. Their diamond viewer allows the customers to view their diamond on a large HD screen instead of a microscope or jewelers loop. CDI offers one of Columbus’s most affordable selection of engagement rings. They carry bridal jewelry lines from the following designers Carrizza, Romance, Mars, and CDI exclusive collection of wedding bands. Also, CDI has a large inventory of diamonds to meet any budget or style. Their fashion jewelry line includes Lafonn and Elle along with the CDI Diamond Fashion Collection. CDI provides our customers the additional following services jewelry repair appraisals, and financing.

6. Worthington Jewelers Go to the the online store

6. Worthington Jewelers

Since 2000, Worthington Jewelers has offered one-of-a-kind jewelry to celebrate once-in-a-lifetime events. Family owned Worthington Jewelers was created to give central Ohio customers a source for high-quality yet affordable one-of-a-kind jewelry. Committed to customer education, we’ll help you make informed decisions about the metals, diamonds and gemstones used in making your jewelry. As your personal jeweler, they’re also here to maintain your fine jewelry for a lifetime of enjoyment. Jewelry cleaning and inspections are always free, and they offer a full range of repair and appraisal services. Engaged in the local community, Worthington Jewelers supports area schools, arts organizations and other community groups. They are members of the Worthington Area Chamber of Commerce and the Old Worthington Business Association. Worthington Jewelers is committed to the highest professional standards. They are members of the  Ohio Jewelers Association, Jewelers of America, Jewelers Vigilance Committee and the International Gem Society.  They are listed with the Jewelers Board of Trade. Child and dog-friendly, Worthington Jewelers offers a relaxed and enjoyable shopping environment. They hope you’ll stop by soon to learn what has made us one of the fastest-growing jewelers in central Ohio.

7. Grandview Mercantile Go to the the online store

7. Grandview Mercantile

Grandview Mercantile is a 22,000 square foot antique and fine home consignments marketplace showcasing 20 of central Ohio's premier antique dealers and over 500 consignors. They offer a wide assortment of curated antique and vintage items plus previously owned designer and one of a kind furniture, fine art and decorative accessories. It is the largest store of its kind in the Midwest. With our ever changing and unique assortment of "Fabulous Finds", Grandview Mercantile is "the place to shop" if you are looking for something truly special.

Popular products near you

Popular Blog Posts

Ten Independent Jewelry Stores to Check Out in Los Angeles

Shopping jewelry can be a difficult task for you if you are doing it...

read more

Ten Coolest Jewelry Stores in New York City

When it comes to cool jewelry, no one does it quite like the big app...

read more

Most Trusted Jewelry Stores in Salt Lake City

It can be difficult for a customer to trust a jewelry store when vis...

read more

Shopping for Jewelry in Las Vegas? Check out 8 of our favorite stores

When you decide to purchase diamonds and other fine jewelry and gift...

read more

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Get the best news about jewelry and watch industries, products and services